Essay on articles of confederation vs the constitution

Originally, it governed approximately 4 million citizens of the 13 original states.

argumentative essay on the constitution

Additionally, the Constitution gave Congress the mandate of making decisions pertaining to conflicts, peace, and engaging in foreign relations. Supporters of the document paid a hard won battle to win ratification by the necessary nine out of thirteen U.

Another compromise reached was The Three-fifths Compromise.

Confederation and the constitution

Drafting of new constitution was not an easy job. This new constitution was signed by the members of the Constitutional Convention on September 17, …show more content… Similarly, when Congress decided to develop western land acquired by US through Paris treaty, Congress failed to reach on any conclusion. Constitution Confederation and Constitution After fighting the British in the Revolutionary War, our new independent nation faced some difficult and challenging times economically. Don't waste time. On this issue, all the states were divided. Also, the Constitution provided respective courts with the jurisdiction to solve the disputes arising among different jurisdictions. Even though the government under the Articles of Confederation was very weak, it was still more democratic because it gave more rights and power to the states. The AOC offered no regulation of trade between states and interstate commerce. Get a complete paper today. Related posts:. But they differ more than they do resemble each other, when one looks at the details.

This new constitution was signed by the members of the Constitutional Convention on September 17, …show more content… Similarly, when Congress decided to develop western land acquired by US through Paris treaty, Congress failed to reach on any conclusion. A draft of the Constitution was released in after ten years of reliance on the articles.

Articles of confederation vs constitution compare and contrast essay

The AOC had no executive power; the president of the United States simply presided over Congress until the ratification of the Constitution which created the Executive branch. On the other hand, the structure of the government as provided for in the Constitution was stratified into tri-divisions namely; the judiciary, legislature, and executive. On June 21, , the U. The Organization of the Constitution vs. To ratify the Constitution it was determined that 9 of the 13 states had to agree to the ratification in order for the new Constitution to go into effect. In contrast, William Paterson submitted the New Jersey Plan which merely amended the Articles by giving the federal government more power. In regard to these responsibilities and powers bestowed on Congress, the Confederation Articles were bound to fail since they greatly limited the sovereignty of Congress. Related posts:. James Madison proposed the Virginia Plan, a plan which advocated a balanced, three-branch method of government with a bicameral, or two-house, Congress. Some of the weaknesses of these Articles were economic disorganization, lack of central government power, and legislative inefficiencies. Sovereignty was an issue while the AOC were in place as it resided in the states whereas the Constitution created the supreme law of the land. The weaknesses of this first form of government were eventually seen and the U.

The attempt by a new country to unite itself and form a national government. This plan as well called for a Chief Executive and a Federal Court system, and it gave Congress the power to tax and regulate interstate commerce.

Why was the articles of confederation replaced by the constitution

The constitutions are both similar in retrospect but when one compares them directly the differences out lay the similarities The Articles unified the states, which lacked a strong, central government. This new constitution was signed by the members of the Constitutional Convention on September 17, …show more content… Similarly, when Congress decided to develop western land acquired by US through Paris treaty, Congress failed to reach on any conclusion. Under the Articles, the central government could not effectively act on critical matters such as public finance, trade, and defense since it relied on the decisions made by the respective state legislatures. Under the Articles, a Continental Congress had been shaped, which was allocated virtually no authority to collect revenue, handle domestic affairs, or control commercial trade. Today, it governs over million citizens of the 52 states and has been subjected 27 amendments. Elliot, Jonathan. Sovereignty was an issue while the AOC were in place as it resided in the states whereas the Constitution created the supreme law of the land. The weaknesses of the AOC had to be addressed.

It was at this convention that many plans were proposed, and compromises were reached.

Rated 7/10 based on 91 review
Download
Articles of Confederation vs Constitution Essay Example